Replacement chess pieces: how to find a match for a lost or broken piece

Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. This guide is based on published standards and research; see how we research.

A missing pawn or a knight with a snapped ear doesn’t mean the whole set is finished. Depending on the set, you can buy a single matching piece, replace just the pieces and keep the board, or repair what you have. Here’s how to work out which option fits.

Step 1: Measure what you have

Before you search, gather the details a seller will ask for. Use a ruler or calipers and measure in both inches and centimetres, since listings use both.

Measure	How	Why it matters
King height	Base to top of the cross	Sets are sold by king height (“3.75-inch king”)
King base diameter	Across the widest part of the base	Confirms the size and the fit on your board
Height of the piece you’re replacing	Measure the same piece in the other colour	The replacement should be the same height
Base diameter of that piece	As above	Stops a replacement looking chunky or skinny

If you’ve lost a piece of one colour, the matching piece of the other colour is your best template. It’s the same shape and size, only the finish differs.

Chess House notes on its replacement pieces page that sizes in product titles refer to the king, with the other pieces’ sizes given in the description. That’s typical across the market, so always compare like with like.

Step 2: Note the pattern, finish and weight

Pattern. Most sets are Staunton pattern, but “Staunton” covers a lot of variation, especially in the knight. Take clear photos of the matching piece from the front and side. Our Staunton pieces guide explains what to look for.

Colour and finish. For wood, note the species if you know it (boxwood, ebony, rosewood, sheesham) and whether the dark pieces are real ebony or stained (“ebonized”). Our woods guide helps here. Note whether the finish is glossy or matte. For plastic, note the exact shade: white versus ivory or cream makes a visible difference.

Weight. Pick up the matching piece and compare it with others. A heavy, weighted set will make a light replacement feel obviously wrong in the hand. See our weighted vs. unweighted guide.

Markings. Look under the felt and on the box for a maker’s name or product code. That’s the fastest route to an exact match.

Step 3: Pick your replacement route

Use a spare queen

Many tournament and club sets come with two extra queens for pawn promotion. If you’ve lost a queen, check the box first. A spare queen can’t stand in for a different piece, though.

Contact the maker or original seller

If you know who made the set, ask them. Some makers sell single pieces for their current sets. For example, World Chess sells individual replacement pieces for its official championship set, one piece and colour at a time. Expect a single piece from a premium maker to cost noticeably more than you’d guess for one small piece of wood.

Buy a single replacement piece from a retailer

Some retailers sell individual pieces matched to the sets they stock. Chess House has a single and replacement pieces section with pieces in wood, plastic and other materials, plus felt circles for bases. It advises that pieces with an exact product code match will blend in with your existing set. Single plastic pieces are usually very cheap; wooden ones cost more.

This works best when your set came from that retailer. A “close” match from a different maker will often differ slightly in shape or shade.

Buy a full set of pieces (no board)

For many sets this is the most practical answer, especially when:

you can’t identify the maker,
you’ve lost more than one piece, or
the set is an inexpensive one where a whole new set of pieces costs little more than shipping on one.

Keep your board and choose replacement pieces with a king base that suits your squares; our size guide explains the fit. Keep the old pieces as spares.

For antiques and heirlooms

Old sets are much harder to match. Collectors and antique dealers sometimes sell odd pieces, but expect to search for a while. For a valuable set, a professional restorer may be a better choice than a mismatched piece.

Repairs you can do at home

A loose or snapped-off head

For a clean break on a wooden piece, players on the Chess.com forum generally recommend a wood glue or PVA glue (white or yellow) rather than super glue. The approach they describe:

Dry-fit the pieces to check alignment.
Apply a very small amount of glue so it doesn’t squeeze out.
Press the pieces together in their exact original position and hold until the glue starts to grab.
Wrap masking tape tightly around the joint as a clamp and leave it to cure.
Wipe off any squeeze-out with a damp cloth while it’s still wet.

A clean break can be almost invisible afterwards; a jagged one will usually show. Plastic pieces need a glue made for plastic.

A rattling piece

A rattle usually means the weight inside the base has come loose. Chess.com’s guide to fixing this involves lifting the felt, taking out the weight, partly filling the cavity with clear silicone sealant, setting the weight back in, and gluing the felt back with a thin bead of the same silicone. Leave it standing upright on a disposable surface to cure (the guide suggests around 12 hours), then trim any excess so the piece sits level.

Re-felting

Worn, dirty or peeling felt can be replaced. Self-adhesive felt circles are sold in common sizes, or you can cut your own from felt or billiard cloth and glue it on. Tips from the Chess.com forum:

Clean the base before gluing.
Use a thin layer of glue, because too much can soak through the felt or leave a bump.
Press the piece down under light weight while it sets.

Re-felting one piece usually means you’ll want to do the whole set so they all match. New felt also protects the board, which our board care guide covers.

Where to buy

Search single replacement chess pieces (plastic pieces are usually inexpensive)
Search weighted plastic replacement pieces with a 3.75” king
Browse single and replacement pieces at Chess House
Browse wooden chess sets at Chess House
Browse luxury chess pieces at Chess House (for replacing a whole set of pieces)